A viral claim suggesting Wall Street firms purchased 44% of American homes in 2023 has been making the rounds. However, according to a new HousingWire analysis, this narrative is far from reality.
Data from Freddie Mac reveals that large institutional buyers—defined as those purchasing 100 or more homes annually—have never exceeded a 2.5% market share since 2000, even at their peak. In fact, as of Q2 2023, institutional buyers with portfolios of over 1,000 homes accounted for a mere 0.4% of the market.
Breaking Down the Numbers
While overall investor activity has grown, with investors accounting for about 30% of housing purchases, most of this stems from small-scale buyers acquiring between one and nine properties. The idea that Wall Street firms dominate the housing market doesn’t hold up when you dive into the data.
Recent mortgage application trends also challenge the narrative. Institutional investors often make all-cash purchases, yet increasing mortgage demand suggests that traditional homebuyers are driving the market. Each time mortgage rates dip toward 6%, there’s a noticeable surge in applications from primary residence buyers.
The Role of Generational Shifts
Market dynamics are better explained by generational trends than by institutional activity. According to the National Association of Realtors, Millennials dominated home purchases from 2013 until rising interest rates in 2022 shifted the balance to Gen X and Baby Boomers.
Additionally, the current low housing inventory isn’t the result of institutional “hoarding” but broader market forces. Companies often associated with the Wall Street housing narrative, such as BlackRock and Blackstone, maintain relatively small residential portfolios compared to the overall housing stock.
Small Investors Drive the Market
Data from John Burns Real Estate highlights the differing strategies of small and large investors. Mom-and-pop buyers typically target properties needing renovations or offering steady rental income in growing communities. Meanwhile, institutional buyers tend to focus on newly constructed homes in select markets.
This illustrates a significant disconnect between social media-fueled misconceptions and market reality. While investor participation in housing has grown over the past two decades, it’s primarily driven by individual buyers, not Wall Street institutions.
What This Means for the Housing Market
Claims of Wall Street’s overwhelming dominance in housing don’t align with the facts. Instead, individual buyers remain the primary drivers of housing demand, with institutional activity playing a minor role.
If you’re looking to invest in real estate without becoming a landlord, consider exploring fractional real estate investment opportunities or private credit funds, which offer exposure to real estate-backed assets with low minimum investments.